My letter to the Assistant Chief Executive and Chief Librarian of the National Library Board
July 9, 2014, 3:23 am
Filed under: By Rachel Zeng, Singapore

Ms Tay Ai Ching
Assistant Chief Executive and Chief Librarian
Public Library Services Group
National Library Board

Dear Ms Tay,

I am writing in response to the news that two books have been taken off the catalogue and shelves of your libraries after receiving feedback that these books run in contrary to Singapore’s “pro-family” position.

I would like to emphasise that the two books which have been withdrawn from your shelves, are in no way contrary to Singapore’s “pro-family” position. As experience has informed me, “atypical” family units, for the lack of a better term, have been wrongly misunderstood and discriminated for far too long.

Having been an early childhood educator for the past 10 years, I have met and worked with children from different family backgrounds. While most of them come from the typical family unit consisting of biological parents who are in a heterosexual union, there are some who come from single parent families. I have also met children with parents of the same gender, as well as children living with adopted or foster parents. In most of these families, there exist a large amount of love and care despite the common fallacy that only families that derived from heterosexual unions are morally functional.

Due to society’s over-emphasis on what a typical family unit should be, some children from “atypical” family backgrounds do sometimes feel out of place. Being the odd ones out can hamper young children’s socio-emotional development, which in turn affects other areas of development. Hence, it is highly important that educators make the effort to create an inclusive learning environment that encourages acceptance and respect for one another. Furthermore it is the responsibility of educators to expose our students to concepts that exist in reality, in order to inculcate a sense of acceptance and respect for diversity within the local and global communities. This is one of the key purposes of education.

To achieve the abovementioned goals, educators should ideally provide materials that go beyond the narrow scope of what constitutes “normality” or “typicality”. This includes books such as And Tango Makes Three by Richardson and Parnell (2005), and The White Swan Express by Okimoto and Aoki (2002). Therefore I view the news with severe disappointment, especially when similar materials are few and rare in this overly conservative society.

Last but not least as a resource centre of knowledge, the National Library Board (NLB) should maintain a diverse collection of reading materials in your libraries that will cater to the educational needs of everyone from as young as 18 months old to those who are 60 and beyond. It should not limit the availability of knowledge by pandering to the standards of a conservative minority. I would like to take this opportunity to implore the NLB to put these two books back on the shelves of your libraries, as well as acquire a wider variety of such materials for the educational well-being of the public that the board seeks to serve.

Thank you.

Yours sincerely,
Rachel Zeng (Ms)

5 Comments so far
Leave a comment

[…] Blogfather: Dear NLB – Singling out Penguins & Swans – Rachel Zeng’s Blog: My letter to the Assistant Chief Executive and Chief Librarian of the National Library Board – [FB] Melissa Tsang: Letter to the NLB – gay penguins, children’s books, family […]

Pingback by Daily SG: 9 Jul 2014 | The Singapore Daily

Discoveries, cultures and many good records were lost in ancient China because new dynasties viewed those records as running contrary to the new ‘government’ then.
Such erosion of knowledge eventually led the last dynasty to ruins and China labelled as the ‘sick man of Asia’ then.

Comment by ape@kinjioleaf

[…] fierce reactions from the reading public, especially mothers and academics. Educator Rachel Zeng urged the NLB to resist the threat of the conservative […]

Pingback by Singapore’s Libraries Don’t Want Kids Reading About Tango the Penguin and His Two Loving Fathers · Global Voices

[…] parte del pubblico di lettori, in particolar modo dalle madri e dai docenti. La docente Rachel Zeng ha esortato la NLB a resistere alla minaccia della minoranza […]

Pingback by Singapore: censurato in biblioteca ‘Tango il pinguino e i suoi due amorevoli papà’ · Global Voices in Italiano

[…] この決定は、特に母親や学術関係者を中心に、愛読家のシンガポール人の激しい反発を呼ぶことになった。教育専門家のレイチェル・ゼン氏は、少数保守派からの脅しに屈しないようNLBに迫った。 […]

Pingback by ゲイのペンギン2匹の子育てを描いた絵本、シンガポールの図書館で閲覧禁止に · Global Voices 日本語

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: